What Are The Three Substantive Defenses?
Discover the three substantive defenses in criminal law: self-defense, insanity, and duress. Learn how these defenses can exonerate you under Utah law.
What Are The Three Substantive Defenses?
When you are facing legal challenges, especially in criminal cases, it’s important to understand the defenses available to you. Substantive defenses are critical because they can potentially exonerate you from a charge. Understanding these defenses can empower you and provide clarity during a difficult time. In this article, we’ll dive deep into the three substantive defenses according to Utah law, breaking down complex legal jargon and illustrating key points with relatable examples.
Introduction to Substantive Defenses
Substantive defenses in criminal law refer to arguments that, if proven, negate or mitigate the defendant’s criminal liability. Unlike procedural defenses, which focus on how the legal system operates, substantive defenses address the core issue of whether a crime was committed by the defendant. These defenses are built around the premise that either the defendant didn’t commit the crime, or there were circumstances justifying their actions.
Substantive defenses include:
- Self-Defense
- Insanity
- Duress
Let’s explore each of these defenses in detail and understand their application under Utah law.
Self-Defense
Self-defense is one of the most common substantive defenses. It asserts that the defendant acted to protect themselves from imminent harm. The use of force, according to this defense, was necessary and reasonable under the circumstances.
Self-Defense Under Utah Law
In Utah, self-defense is codified under Utah Code §76–2–402. It states that an individual is justified in using force to defend themselves or another person if they reasonably believe that such force is necessary to prevent imminent harm, death, or serious bodily injury.
Conditions for Self-Defense
- Imminent Threat: The danger must be immediate and unavoidable.
- Reasonable Force: The level of force used must be proportional to the threat.
- No Provocation: The defendant must not have instigated the situation.
Example Scenario
Imagine you are in Salt Lake City walking home late at night when someone aggressively approaches you with a knife demanding your wallet. Fearing for your safety, you manage to disarm the attacker and use the knife to keep them at bay until the police arrive. In this situation, you acted in self-defense since the threat was immediate, and your response was proportional to the threat.
It’s crucial to note that self-defense is not a carte blanche to use violence; it must be justified and reasonable under the circumstances. Misconceptions often arise around what constitutes ‘reasonable’ force, hence understanding the law’s nuances is essential.
Additional Resources
If you need further guidance or have specific questions about self-defense, the West Jordan Lawyer Jeremy Eveland is a great resource.
Insanity Defense
The insanity defense is based on the principle that a person should not be held criminally responsible if they were incapable of understanding the nature and wrongfulness of their actions due to a severe mental defect or illness.
Insanity Defense Under Utah Law
Utah follows the M’Naghten Rule for insanity, codified under Utah Code §77–16a-101. This rule states that a defendant can be found legally insane if, at the time of the crime, they were suffering from such a severe mental illness that they couldn’t understand the nature of their actions or distinguish right from wrong.
Conditions for the Insanity Defense
- Severe Mental Illness: The defendant must have a diagnosed serious mental condition.
- Inability to Understand Actions: The defendant must lack the capacity to understand their actions due to their mental state.
- Moral Incapacity: The defendant cannot differentiate between right and wrong.
Example Scenario
Consider a scenario in Provo where someone with a documented history of severe schizophrenia commits a crime while experiencing a particularly intense psychotic episode. If they genuinely believed their actions were justifiable because their perception of reality was significantly altered, the insanity defense might apply.
Despite its potential viability, the insanity defense is rarely successful and often misunderstood. It’s not intended to absolve the defendant of consequences but to ensure that individuals who are genuinely incapable of understanding their wrongdoing receive appropriate treatment rather than punishment.
Duress
The defense of duress involves a situation where a person commits a crime because they were forced or threatened by another person to do so. The key aspect here is that the defendant had no reasonable alternative but to comply with the threats.
Duress Under Utah Law
Duress is addressed under Utah Code §76–2–302. It states that a person is not criminally responsible if they committed an offense because they reasonably believed they would face imminent death or serious bodily harm if they did not comply.
Conditions for Duress
- Imminent Threat: The defendant must have faced a significant and immediate threat.
- No Reasonable Escape: The defendant must have had no opportunity to escape or avoid the threat.
- Reasonable Belief: The fear must be objectively reasonable under the circumstances.
Example Scenario
Imagine living in a small town in Weber County, where you’re coerced into committing a theft by threats from a dangerous gang. They threaten to harm your family if you don’t comply. If captured by law enforcement, you could invoke duress as a defense by demonstrating that the threats left you with no other feasible alternative.
Common Misconceptions
Self-Defense Misconceptions
- It’s a Free Pass: Many believe self-defense justifies any level of force. In reality, it must be proportional to the threat.
- After the Threat: Using force after the threat has subsided is not justified.
Insanity Defense Misconceptions
- Often Used: The insanity defense is rarely used and even less frequently successful.
- Avoids Punishment: It doesn’t absolve responsibility but redirects to mental health treatment.
Duress Misconceptions
- Applicable Anytime: Duress applies only when there’s an imminent threat and no possible escape.
- Covers All Crimes: Duress is not a blanket defense and doesn’t cover particularly heinous crimes like murder.
Practical Application and Importance
Understanding these defenses helps you navigate legal complexities if you or someone you know are facing criminal charges. In real-world applications:
- Educating Yourself: Being informed about your rights can influence case outcomes.
- Legal Representation: Knowing when to invoke these defenses can shape your legal strategy.
- Avoiding Pitfalls: Misunderstanding the scope and application can have severe consequences.
1. Can self-defense be used in any type of crime?
Self-defense can primarily be used in cases involving violent crimes. It’s essential that the use of force was necessary and proportionate to prevent imminent harm.
2. How can one prove an insanity defense?
Proving insanity involves presenting substantial medical evidence and expert testimony to demonstrate a severe mental illness that impacts understanding of actions.
3. Can duress be used to excuse all criminal behavior?
No, duress is limited to situations involving imminent threats and doesn’t cover extreme crimes like murder. The defendant must also show they had no reasonable alternative.
4. Does claiming one of these defenses guarantee a not guilty verdict?
Not necessarily. Each defense requires substantial proof and is subject to the court’s evaluation. The success of these defenses depends on the evidence presented and legal arguments made.
Final Takeaway
To speak with a criminal defense attorney, call Jeremy Eveland Utah Lawyer (801) 613–1472. Remember, legal defenses are intricate and specific to each case’s context. Expert legal advice is always recommended when navigating criminal charges.
Knowing your rights and understanding substantive defenses empower you to face legal challenges confidently. Your grasp of these defenses can significantly influence decisions and outcomes in complex legal scenarios.
If you found this article helpful, please clap, leave a comment, and subscribe to our Medium newsletter for updates! Jeremy Eveland 8833 S Redwood Rd West Jordan Utah 84088 (801) 613–1472
